11 Pokémon Garage Sale Finds Worth Money on eBay (2026)
easyflip

11 Pokémon Garage Sale Finds Worth Money on eBay (2026)

11 Pokémon garage sale finds ranked by real eBay sold prices, from Tomy figures ($45 a lot) to a 1st Edition holo (about $710), plus how to spot fakes.

The short answer

Which Pokémon items from garage sales sell for the most on eBay?

By median US eBay sale (early October to Nov 18, 2026): a raw 1st Edition Base Set holo, leaving out Charizard (about $710), a sealed early Wizards of the Coast booster pack (about $455), a raw Base Set Charizard ($325) and a real Pokémon Emerald cartridge ($240). The box, and whether it's real, moved the price most.

  • A raw 1st Edition Base Set holo (not Charizard) had a median of about $710 on 41 eBay sales of $300 or more (Oct 3-Nov 11, 2026), the top of the list.
  • The box multiplies old games: a loose Pokémon Red, Blue or Yellow cart had a $60 median (84 sales), while 14 complete-in-box copies had a median of about $400.
  • A real Pokémon Emerald cart had a $240 median (46 sales, Oct 28-Nov 18, 2026); 22 more 'brand new' Emeralds at $7-$30 were almost certainly reproductions.
  • Graded Base Set Charizards had a $460 median on 59 sales against $325 raw: only top grades (a CGC 10 got $6,701.75, one sale) make grading pay.
  • Vintage plush ($13 median used) and loose 1999 Burger King toys (about $10) look valuable but usually aren't.
Chapters (16)

These are 11 Pokémon things you can actually find at garage sales, ranked by what they really sold for on eBay. Every price below is a real US eBay sold listing from early October to Nov 18, 2026, with how to spot each one from across the driveway, how to tell a fake, and when grading is worth it.

The short version: the box, and whether it's real, kept moving the price. A loose Pokémon Red cartridge had a $60 median. Complete in its box, the median was about $400.

How were these Pokémon items ranked?

Each item is ranked by its median eBay sale, the sale right in the middle, so one crazy sale can't win on its own. Accepted best offers and anything that looked like a reproduction were left out.

Each one is ranked in its most common form: a loose cartridge, a raw (ungraded) card, one pack, a bag of figures. Pokémon Colosseum is the one exception: it's ranked complete in its case. Disc only, it would still be No. 8.

A card listing the forms each item was ranked in: loose cart, raw card, one pack, a bag of figures
Each item is ranked in the form you usually find it

The 11 Pokémon garage sale finds at a glance

#ItemSold for (median)Most sold forSoldWhat to look for
11Tomy figures (a lot)$45$25-$12036 lots, Oct 28-Nov 18, 2026Tomy and CGTSJ on the bottom, with 1998 or 1999
10Pokémon Red, Blue or Yellow (loose cart)$60$45-$7084 carts, Oct 28-Nov 18, 2026Nintendo Game Boy molded into the plastic up top
9Ancient Mew promo (opened)$75$47-$9592 cards, Nov 12-18, 2026Still in the movie wrapper? Don't open it
8Pokémon Colosseum (complete)about $140$136-$16520 copies, Nov 3-13, 2026The case and manual; a second bonus-disc case
7Pokémon HeartGold (cart only)about $147$140-$15526 carts, Nov 8-18, 2026Dark reddish purple under a bright light; the Pokéwalker
6Pokémon Crystal (loose cart)$150$140-$17044 carts, Oct 28-Nov 17, 2026See-through blue cart; a fresh save battery
5A binder of old cardsabout $158$70-$46560 binders, Oct 28-Nov 18, 2026The holos inside; Wizards in the tiny print
4Pokémon Emerald (real loose cart)$240$215-$26546 carts, Oct 28-Nov 18, 2026AGB-BPEE-USA on the label
3Base Set Charizard (unlimited, raw)$325$250-$39579 cards at $150+, Nov 10-18, 2026Card 4/102, no stamp, Wizards in the copyright line
2Sealed early WOTC booster packabout $455$355-$62077 packs, Oct 19-Nov 17, 2026Crinkly foil in totes and drawers; resealed packs exist
11st Edition Base Set holo (raw, not Charizard)about $710$400-$95041 cards at $300+, Oct 3-Nov 11, 2026The black Edition 1 stamp at the left, under the art

All eBay US sold listings. "Most sold for" is the middle half of the sales.

How much are vintage Tomy Pokémon figures worth?

A bag of them had a $45 median: 36 lots sold from Oct 28 to Nov 18, 2026. These are the two-inch plastic Pokémon that Tomy and Hasbro put out starting in 1998.

Singles are small money. 64 singles and small sets sold, with a $20 median, and most went for $13 to $33. A single Charizard got $22.50 on Nov 14, 2026.

The money is in the bag. A lot of 20 got $61 with 46 bids on Nov 18, 2026. A lot with Venusaur, Charizard, Blastoise and Mewtwo got $210.50 with 33 bids on Nov 1, and a lot of 55 got $314.99 on Nov 1, 2026. That's one sale, not a typical price.

At a sale, check the kids' toy bin. Flip one over and look for Tomy and CGTSJ on the bottom, with 1998 or 1999. Sell them as a lot, and put Charizard and Mewtwo in the first photo.

How much are Pokémon Red, Blue and Yellow worth?

A loose cartridge had a $60 median: 84 sold from Oct 28 to Nov 18, 2026, most for $45 to $70. Red and Blue came out in the US in September 1998, the first Pokémon games outside Japan, and Yellow followed in October 1999.

A Red cartridge got $69 on Nov 16, 2026, and a tested Blue got $64.99 the next day.

Now find the box. 14 complete-in-box copies sold with a median of about $400, and a Yellow with its trainer's guide got $399.99 on Nov 12, 2026. That's more than six times the loose cartridge, just for the box and the papers.

Drawing of the loose cartridge median of $60 next to a box and a much bigger stack of cash at the boxed median of about $400
Loose $60 vs. about $400 complete in box

In a shoebox of games, they're the bright red, blue and yellow ones. Look for Nintendo Game Boy molded into the plastic up top. A gray Pokémon Red with an English label is a fake: the US ones came in color.

How much is the Ancient Mew card worth?

An opened Ancient Mew had a $75 median: 92 sold in one week (Nov 12-18, 2026), most for $47 to $95. In July 2000, US theaters handed this card out with admission the first week of Pokémon the Movie 2000, sealed in a clear wrapper.

One got $60.95 with 8 bids on Nov 18, 2026, and one listed as near mint got $91 with 11 bids.

If it's still in the movie wrapper, don't open it. 25 sealed ones sold that same week with a median of $137.50, and one got $130.50 with 44 bids. A PSA 10 got $2,400 on Nov 18, 2026, but that's one sale, and a gem mint 10.

It turns up in old binders and junk drawers. It's the shiny Mew with strange symbols instead of English words.

How much is Pokémon Colosseum worth?

Complete in its case, about $140: 20 complete copies sold from Nov 3 to 13, 2026. Colosseum came out for the GameCube in March 2004.

A tested Player's Choice copy got $150 on Nov 9, 2026, and a tested black-label copy got $184.99 the same day.

Without the case and manual, it drops. Nine disc-only copies had a median of about $81, like one that got $81 with 29 bids on Nov 11, 2026.

Check the pile for a second case. Preorders in North America came with a separate bonus disc, and most of the eight that sold went for $275 to $300 (Nov 1-13, 2026).

How much is Pokémon HeartGold worth, and how do you spot a fake?

A loose HeartGold cartridge had a median of about $147: 26 sold from Nov 8 to 18, 2026, most for $140 to $155. It came out for the Nintendo DS in March 2010 in a big box with the Pokéwalker, a little step counter you walk your Pokémon on.

One went to auction and got $162.50 with 40 bids, and another got $150 on Nov 18, 2026.

Then it climbs. Complete without the Pokéwalker, the median was about $210. With it, about $300 across six sales, and a big-box copy with the Pokéwalker got $399.99 on Nov 10, 2026.

Drawing of a dark DS cartridge held under a lamp, labeled check the cartridge
The HeartGold light test

Check the cartridge. A real HeartGold looks black, but hold it up to a bright light and it shows a dark reddish purple. A gray one is fake. The same search had 17 HeartGolds listed brand new for $19 to $38; they were left out.

How much is Pokémon Crystal worth?

A loose cartridge had a $150 median: 44 sold from Oct 28 to Nov 17, 2026, most for $140 to $170. Crystal came out for the Game Boy Color in July 2001, and it's the see-through blue cartridge.

A tested one got $144 on Nov 17, 2026, and one with a brand-new battery got $165 the same day. That battery keeps your save and runs the game's clock, and it doesn't last forever, so buyers pay more for a new one.

Boxed copies are a different world: one in its box with the manual got $600 with 25 bids, and a complete one got $1,125 on Nov 11, 2026. One sale.

How much is a binder of old Pokémon cards worth?

A binder collection had a median of about $158: 60 sold from Oct 28 to Nov 18, 2026, most for $70 to $465. The binder is just the container. The cards inside are the price.

A binder of 200-plus cards with an Ash and Pikachu cover got $100 on Nov 16, 2026. Then come the holos. A 400-card binder, old and newer cards mixed, got $1,175 with 46 bids. A collection with 60-plus holos got $2,025 with 42 bids, and a binder with 216 holos got $2,850 on Nov 7, 2026. One sale.

If you don't see one on the table, ask if they have any Pokémon cards. In 2023, a Reddit user posted that they paid $50 for a garage-sale binder and found a reverse holo Blastoise inside (their claim, as reported by Dexerto). Flip to the shiny pages first, and look for Wizards in the tiny print at the bottom. If cards are the main event, our Top 10 Pokémon cards by real eBay sold prices goes card by card.

How much is Pokémon Emerald worth, and how do you tell a fake?

A real loose Emerald cartridge had a $240 median: 46 sold from Oct 28 to Nov 18, 2026, most for $215 to $265. It came out for the Game Boy Advance in May 2005, and it's the see-through green cartridge.

One with a new battery got $240 on Nov 16, 2026. Another got $281 with 44 bids. Complete in the box with its poster, one got $1,000 on Oct 30, 2026. One sale.

Now the fake. In that same search, 22 more Emerald sales went for $7 to $30, mostly listed brand new. One got $8 on Nov 18, 2026. That's almost certainly a reproduction, and none of them are in the range above.

Check three things:

  • Game Boy Advance molded into the plastic.
  • A printed code on the label: AGB-BPEE-USA.
  • On real ones, often a tiny number stamped into the sticker.

No single check proves it, but a brand-new Emerald for eight bucks is the giveaway. Once you've found a real one, EasyFlip writes the eBay listing from a few photos.

How much is a Base Set Charizard worth, and should you grade it?

A raw (ungraded) unlimited Base Set Charizard had a $325 median: 79 raw copies sold for $150 or more from Nov 10 to 18, 2026, most for $250 to $395. This is the regular one, no 1st Edition stamp: card 4/102, from 1999.

One got $296 with 25 bids on Nov 17, 2026, and one got $362 with 69 bids the day before.

Raw vs graded comparison card: raw median $325, all graded median $460 across 59 sales
Raw median $325 vs. graded median $460

Should you grade it? A CGC 9 got $1,950 on Nov 14, 2026, and a CGC 10 got $6,701.75 on Nov 18, 2026. One sale. But 59 graded copies had a median of just $460: the big money is only at the top grades. ICv2 reported that PSA reopened its Value tier on Oct 29, 2026 at $39.99 a card, with a wait of 90 to 100 business days. So grading only pays when the card is close to perfect.

In this search, a Charizard selling for $20 to $100 usually wasn't a real one. Real ones from 1999 say Wizards in the copyright line.

How much is a sealed vintage Pokémon booster pack worth?

A single sealed pack from the early Wizards of the Coast sets (1999 to 2002) had a median of about $455: 77 sold from Oct 19 to Nov 17, 2026, most for $355 to $620.

A Base Set 2 pack got $457 with 17 bids, and a Gym Challenge pack got $466 with 25 bids. A 1st Edition Neo Genesis pack got $1,199.99, and a Base Set pack listed as heavy got $1,810 with 69 bids on Nov 8, 2026. One sale.

Look in totes of old toys and kitchen drawers for that crinkly foil. If one's priced way below normal online, be careful: resealed packs exist. And whatever you do, don't open it.

How do you tell a 1st Edition Pokémon card?

Look for a small black Edition 1 stamp at the left, under the picture. That marks the very first English print run, in 1999, and it's No. 1 on this list.

Leaving out Charizard, 41 raw 1st Edition Base Set holos sold for $300 or more since early October (Oct 3-Nov 11, 2026), with a median of about $710; most went for $400 to $950. An Alakazam got $710 with 35 bids on Nov 7, 2026, and a Blastoise got $1,373 with 27 bids. A raw 1st Edition Charizard got $8,500 on Nov 5, 2026. One sale.

Three drawn holo cards: one with the Edition 1 stamp, one with no stamp and no shadow (shadowless), one with a shadow behind the art (unlimited)
1st Edition, shadowless, unlimited

So in a binder, look at the left edge under the art on every holo:

What you seeWhat it is
Black Edition 1 stamp, left, under the art1st Edition
No stamp and no shadowShadowless
A shadow behind the art boxUnlimited (like the No. 3 Charizard)

Which Pokémon items look valuable but usually aren't?

Vintage plush, Burger King's 1999 toys and the gold-plated Burger King cards. People grab them first, but they usually sell for little.

ItemSold for (median or range)Sold
Vintage plush (used single)$13 median; most $6-$2857, Oct 29-Nov 18, 2026
Burger King 1999 toy (loose single)about $10 median; most $7-$1341, Oct 28-Nov 18, 2026
Burger King gold-plated card (single)20 of 22 sold for $20-$90; Charizard at the top22, Nov 2-10, 2026

A Play By Play Charizard plush got $12.99. The exceptions were one-off sales: an early Tomy Pikachu got $89.99 on Nov 18, 2026, and a big 18-inch Blastoise got $79.99 on Nov 17, 2026.

One safety note. In December 1999, Burger King recalled more than 25 million of its Poké Ball containers, a suffocation risk for kids under three (CPSC, Dec 27, 1999). The toy inside wasn't part of the recall, but leave the balls on the table.

The bottom line

The recap board: all 11 boxes with their medians, from Tomy figures at about $45 a lot to a 1st Edition holo at about $710
All 11, Box 11 to Box 1

This weekend, check the kids' toy bin, the shoebox of games and any binder on the table. Look for the box and papers, because the box is where games jump. Test whether it's real before you pay: the molded shell, the label code, the light test, Wizards in the copyright line. Keep sealed things sealed. And treat every big sale above as one sale: the medians are what a typical find sells for.

Want the next list in your inbox? The Easy Flip newsletter covers what's selling every week.

Questions people ask

How much is a real Pokémon Emerald cartridge worth?

A real loose Pokémon Emerald cart had a $240 median on 46 US eBay sales from Oct 28 to Nov 18, 2026, and most sold for $215 to $265. One complete in its box with the poster got $1,000 on Oct 30, 2026, but that was one sale.

How can you tell if a Pokémon Emerald is fake?

Check for Game Boy Advance molded into the plastic, the printed code AGB-BPEE-USA on the label, and, on real ones, often a tiny number stamped into the sticker. No single check proves it, but a 'brand new' Emerald for a few dollars is the giveaway: 22 sold for $7 to $30 in the same search and were almost certainly reproductions.

How much is the Ancient Mew promo card worth?

Opened, an Ancient Mew had a $75 median on 92 US eBay sales from Nov 12 to 18, 2026, most for $47 to $95. Still sealed in the movie wrapper, the median was $137.50 on 25 sales, so don't open one you find sealed.

Is it worth grading a Base Set Charizard?

Only if it's close to perfect. Raw unlimited Base Set Charizards had a $325 median (Nov 10-18, 2026) and 59 graded copies a $460 median, while a CGC 10 got $6,701.75 (one sale). ICv2 reported PSA's Value tier reopened on Oct 29, 2026 at $39.99 a card with a 90 to 100 business day wait.

How much is a binder of old Pokémon cards worth?

A vintage binder collection had a median of about $158 on 60 US eBay sales from Oct 28 to Nov 18, 2026, and most sold for $70 to $465. The holos inside set the price: a binder with 216 holos got $2,850 on Nov 7, 2026 (one sale).

Are 1999 Burger King Pokémon toys worth anything?

Usually not much: a loose single toy had a median of about $10 on 41 US eBay sales (Oct 28-Nov 18, 2026). Burger King recalled more than 25 million of its 1999 Poké Ball containers for a suffocation risk to kids under three (CPSC, Dec 27, 1999), so leave the balls on the table.

Sources

Prices are eBay sold listings, and every fact below was checked on November 19, 2026.

  1. eBay sold listings (Sold + Completed, US sellers, accepted best offers and likely reproductions left out), sales Oct 3-Nov 18, 2026
  2. Ancient Mew theater giveaway (Anime News Network, June 21, 2000)
  3. Burger King Pokémon ball recall (CPSC, Dec 27, 1999)
  4. PSA Value tier reopened at $39.99 a card (ICv2, Oct 29, 2026)
  5. Spotting fake Pokémon games (iMore, May 28, 2024)
  6. How to spot fake Nintendo games (Nintendo Life, Aug 17, 2023)
  7. The $50 garage-sale binder, a Reddit post (Dexerto, Dec 12, 2023)
  8. Colosseum bonus disc (Nintendo press release via Nintendo World Report)
  9. 1st Edition, shadowless and unlimited prints (Bulbapedia)
Read the full video transcript

A used Base Set Charizard, no grading, sold on eBay for three hundred sixty-two dollars with sixty-nine bids. A real Pokémon Emerald cartridge got two hundred forty, and one that's almost certainly fake sold for eight. And those old Pokémon plush toys? A used one usually sells for about thirteen bucks. I ranked eleven Pokémon things you can actually find at garage sales by what they really sold for on eBay. Games, toys, promo cards, even a whole binder. How to spot each one from across the driveway, how to tell a fake, and when grading is worth it. I've been reselling for years. Let's jump right into it.

The ground rules first. Every price is a real eBay sold listing in the US, from early October to this week. I left out accepted best offers and anything that looked like a reproduction. Then I ranked them by the median, the sale right in the middle, so one crazy sale can't win on its own. And I ranked each one in its most common form: a loose cartridge, a raw card, one pack, a bag of figures. Colosseum is the one exception.

Number eleven: the little Tomy figures. These are the two-inch plastic Pokémon that Tomy and Hasbro put out starting in nineteen ninety-eight. Sixty-four singles and small sets sold, the median was twenty dollars, and the typical ones went for thirteen to thirty-three. A single Charizard got twenty-two fifty on November fourteenth. But the money is in the bag. Thirty-six lots sold, and the median was forty-five. A lot of twenty went to auction and got sixty-one dollars with forty-six bids on November eighteenth. A lot with Venusaur, Charizard, Blastoise and Mewtwo got two hundred ten fifty with thirty-three bids. And a lot of fifty-five got three hundred fourteen ninety-nine on November first. One sale. At a sale, check the kids' toy bin. Flip one over: look for Tomy and CGTSJ on the bottom, with nineteen ninety-eight or ninety-nine. Sell them as a lot, and put Charizard and Mewtwo in the first photo.

Quick thing before we keep going. If you've got a pile of stuff waiting to be listed, that's exactly why I built EasyFlip. Snap a few photos and it writes the whole eBay listing for you: title, description, item specifics, the category, even a price. You check it, tap publish, done. Link's down below.

Number ten: Pokémon Red, Blue and Yellow for the original Game Boy. Red and Blue came out here in September nineteen ninety-eight, the first Pokémon games outside Japan, and Yellow followed in October nineteen ninety-nine. Eighty-four loose cartridges sold, the median was sixty dollars, and the typical ones went for forty-five to seventy. A Red cartridge got sixty-nine on November sixteenth, and a tested Blue got sixty-four ninety-nine the next day. Now find the box. Fourteen complete-in-box copies sold, and the median was about four hundred. A Yellow with its trainer's guide got three ninety-nine ninety-nine on November twelfth. That's more than six times the loose cartridge, just for the box and the papers. In a shoebox of games, they're the bright red, blue and yellow ones. Look for Nintendo Game Boy molded into the plastic up top. And a gray Pokémon Red with an English label is a fake: the US ones came in color.

Number nine: the Ancient Mew. In July two thousand, US theaters handed this card out with admission the first week of Pokémon the Movie two thousand, sealed in a clear wrapper. It sells like crazy. Ninety-two opened copies sold in one week, the median was seventy-five dollars, and the typical ones went for forty-seven to ninety-five. One got sixty ninety-five with eight bids on November eighteenth, and one listed as near mint got ninety-one with eleven bids. If it's still in the movie wrapper, don't open it. Twenty-five sealed ones sold that same week, the median was a hundred thirty-seven fifty, and one got a hundred thirty fifty with forty-four bids. And a PSA ten got twenty-four hundred on November eighteenth. One sale, and that's a gem mint ten. It turns up in old binders and junk drawers. It's the shiny Mew with strange symbols instead of English words.

Number eight: Pokémon Colosseum for the GameCube, from March two thousand four. I ranked this one complete. Disc only, it would still be number eight. Twenty complete copies sold from November third to the thirteenth, and the median was about a hundred forty. A Player's Choice copy, tested, got a hundred fifty on November ninth. A black-label one, tested, got a hundred eighty-four ninety-nine the same day. Without the case and manual, it drops. Nine disc-only copies had a median of about eighty-one, like this one: eighty-one dollars with twenty-nine bids. And check the pile for a second case. Preorders in North America came with a separate bonus disc, and most of the eight that sold went for two seventy-five to three hundred.

Number seven: Pokémon HeartGold for the Nintendo DS. It came out in March twenty ten in a big box with the Pokéwalker, a little step counter you walk your Pokémon on. Twenty-six loose cartridges sold from November eighth to the eighteenth, the median was about a hundred forty-seven, and the typical ones went for a hundred forty to a hundred fifty-five. One went to auction and got a hundred sixty-two fifty with forty bids. Another got a hundred fifty on November eighteenth. Then it climbs. Complete without the Pokéwalker, the median was about two ten. With it, about three hundred across six sales, and a big-box copy with the Pokéwalker got three ninety-nine ninety-nine on November tenth. Check the cartridge. A real HeartGold looks black, but hold it up to a bright light and it shows a dark reddish purple. A gray one is fake. And the same search had seventeen HeartGolds listed brand new for nineteen to thirty-eight dollars. I left those out.

Number six: Pokémon Crystal for the Game Boy Color, from July two thousand one. It's the see-through blue cartridge. Forty-four loose cartridges sold, the median was a hundred fifty, and the typical ones went for a hundred forty to a hundred seventy. A tested one got a hundred forty-four on November seventeenth, and one with a brand-new battery got a hundred sixty-five the same day. That battery keeps your save and runs the game's clock, and it doesn't last forever. Buyers pay more for a new one. And boxed copies are a different world: one in its box with the manual got six hundred with twenty-five bids, and a complete one got eleven twenty-five on November eleventh. One sale.

Number five: the binder. Kids kept their cards in these from nineteen ninety-nine to the early two thousands, and the binder is just the container. The cards inside are the price. Sixty binder collections sold, the median was about a hundred fifty-eight, and the typical ones went for seventy to four sixty-five. A binder of two hundred plus cards with an Ash and Pikachu cover got a hundred dollars on November sixteenth. Then come the holos. A four-hundred-card binder, old and newer cards mixed, went to auction and got eleven seventy-five with forty-six bids. A collection with sixty-plus holos got two thousand twenty-five with forty-two bids. And a binder with two hundred sixteen holos got twenty-eight fifty on November seventh. One sale. If you don't see one on the table, ask if they have any Pokémon cards. In twenty twenty-three, a Reddit user posted that they paid fifty dollars for a garage-sale binder and found a reverse holo Blastoise inside. Flip to the shiny pages first, and look for Wizards in the tiny print at the bottom.

Number four: Pokémon Emerald for the Game Boy Advance, from May two thousand five. It's the see-through green cartridge. Forty-six real loose cartridges sold, the median was two hundred forty, and the typical ones went for two fifteen to two sixty-five. One with a new battery got two forty on November sixteenth. Another went to auction and got two eighty-one with forty-four bids. And complete in the box with its poster, one got a thousand dollars on October thirtieth. One sale. Now the fake. In that same search, twenty-two more Emerald sales went for seven to thirty dollars, mostly listed brand new. Like this one: eight dollars on November eighteenth. That's almost certainly a reproduction. So check three things. Game Boy Advance molded into the plastic. A printed code on the label, A G B dash B P E E dash U S A. And on real ones, often a tiny number stamped into the sticker. No single check proves it, but a brand-new Emerald for eight bucks is the giveaway.

Number three: the Base Set Charizard, the regular one, no first edition stamp. It's card four of a hundred two, from nineteen ninety-nine. Seventy-nine raw copies sold for a hundred fifty or more in nine days, the median was three twenty-five, and the typical ones went for two fifty to three ninety-five. One got two ninety-six with twenty-five bids on November seventeenth, and the one from the start got three sixty-two with sixty-nine bids the day before. So should you grade it? A CGC nine got nineteen fifty on November fourteenth, and a CGC ten got sixty-seven oh one seventy-five on the eighteenth. One sale. But fifty-nine graded copies had a median of just four sixty. The big money is only at the top grades. ICv2 reported that PSA reopened its Value tier on October twenty-ninth at thirty-nine ninety-nine a card, with a wait of ninety to a hundred business days. So grading only pays when the card is close to perfect. And in my search, a Charizard selling for twenty to a hundred bucks usually wasn't a real one. Real ones from nineteen ninety-nine say Wizards in the copyright line.

Number two: a sealed pack from the early Wizards of the Coast sets, nineteen ninety-nine to two thousand two. Seventy-seven single packs sold, the median was about four fifty-five, and the typical ones went for three fifty-five to six twenty. A Base Set two pack got four fifty-seven with seventeen bids, and a Gym Challenge pack got four sixty-six with twenty-five bids. A first edition Neo Genesis pack got eleven ninety-nine ninety-nine. And a Base Set pack listed as heavy got eighteen ten with sixty-nine bids on November eighth. One sale. Look in totes of old toys and kitchen drawers for that crinkly foil. If one's priced way below normal online, be careful: resealed packs exist. And whatever you do, don't open it.

Number one: a first edition Base Set holo. That's the very first English print run in nineteen ninety-nine, with a small black Edition one stamp at the left, under the picture. Leaving out Charizard, forty-one raw ones sold for three hundred or more since early October, the median was about seven ten, and the typical ones went for four hundred to nine fifty. An Alakazam got seven ten with thirty-five bids on November seventh. A Blastoise got thirteen seventy-three with twenty-seven bids. And a raw first edition Charizard got eighty-five hundred on November fifth. One sale. So in a binder, look at the left edge under the art on every holo. No stamp and no shadow is the shadowless print. A shadow behind the art box is unlimited, like our number three.

Now the ones people grab first. Vintage plush: fifty-seven used singles sold, the median was thirteen dollars. A Play By Play Charizard got twelve ninety-nine. The exceptions: an early Tomy Pikachu got eighty-nine ninety-nine, and a big eighteen-inch Blastoise got seventy-nine ninety-nine. Burger King's nineteen ninety-nine toys usually sell for about ten dollars loose. And in December nineteen ninety-nine, Burger King recalled more than twenty-five million of those Poké Ball containers, a suffocation risk for kids under three. The toy inside wasn't part of the recall, but leave the balls on the table. The gold-plated cards from that same promo look like treasure. Most sold for twenty to ninety, and Charizard is the one at the top.

So here's all eleven. Number eleven, Tomy figures, about forty-five a lot. Ten, Red, Blue and Yellow, sixty loose and about four hundred boxed. Nine, Ancient Mew, seventy-five, more sealed. Eight, Colosseum, about a hundred forty complete. Seven, HeartGold, about a hundred forty-seven. Six, Crystal, a hundred fifty. Five, the binder, about a hundred fifty-eight. Four, Emerald, two forty. Three, the Charizard, three twenty-five raw. Two, a sealed pack, about four fifty-five. And number one, a first edition holo, about seven ten. Two things kept moving the price: the box, and whether it's real. What's the best Pokémon thing you've ever found at a garage sale? Drop it in the comments. And if this has you checking the next shoebox of old games, a like helps it reach more resellers. Have a blessed day.